Ranger and Morelli Cast For Stephanie Plum Movie

Ever since I first heard that this movie is happening, I’ve been impatiently waiting to find out who Stephanie Plum’s leading men would be.  I really do dig Katherine Heigl as Stephanie and was really worried that they would go all wrong with the casting of Ranger and Morelli.  I was also keen to see if, by some slim chance, they went with my choices, but no such luck.

That doesn’t mean it’s all bad though… let’s have a little look-see at who will be playing these two men that are so near and dear to our hearts.

JOE MORELLI

morelli

Wikipedia description of the character:

Joe Morelli is Stephanie’s on-and-off boyfriend, a former bad boy turned vice cop. He is also known as Officer Hottie or the Italian Stallion. Her history with Morelli started with a “choo choo” incident when she was six. At the age of sixteen, Stephanie lost her virginity to Morelli in the Tasty Pastry shop behind the éclair stand, after which he never called (but left quite a few flattering messages in bathroom and stadium walls around town). Three years later she saw Morelli and ran over him with her father’s Buick, breaking his leg. A few years later in One for the Money Morelli was suspected of murder and was her first FTA, and Stephanie chased him around town, much to his annoyance….

At various times, both Stephanie and Morelli have seriously considered marriage, but never at the same time. They both know they’re not ready for commitment, but often comment on the idea together and have lived together more than once. Their relationship runs cold as a result of many arguments – usually over her job (She’s been known to stress Morelli enough that he tends to takes Rolaids & Maalox and tells her that he is quickly deteriorating because of her) and they eventually lead to her relationship with Ranger. Being that both were born & bred in Trenton, whatever happens to/around her usually has a number of others calling Morelli to inform him – cars being blown, bodies being found, etc. He’s said that he doesn’t even need to listen to the radio anymore; he knows she’s always involved (usually by some illegal means) and that he always gets calls about her and the latest situation she’s in.

Afraid I’ll have to cut it there as anything else will just spoil it for those of you who aren’t familiar with the story.

Morelli will be played by Jason O’Mara, who is most well known for his leading role in Life on Mars. I have never watched it as I’m not a big fan of shows that originate from trying to rip off really intelligently written British shows, but well… he looks cute enough.  Not exactly what I had in mind for Morelli, but I can see a faint glimmer of it there.  I somehow imagined him to be the real black haired, dark, Italian type, but my choice was Jeffrey Dean Morgan and he doesn’t exactly fit that description either.

I’m not screaming for joy here but I’m not particularly bothered by it either.  It can still go either way for me and I won’t know until I actually see him in the film.  Although, I may set aside my hatred for watered down American versions of British shows and watch Life on Mars, purely for research purposes.  I will have to get back to you on that.

RANGER

ranger2

Wikipedia description of the character:

Ranger is Stephanie’s fellow bounty hunter and tutor and sometimes known as Batman because of his mysterious ways. Ranger is Cuban-American, with mocha latte skin that can only be described as yum, always wears black or camo green, and drives a rotation of very expensive black cars (Stephanie has lingering questions about the origin of Ranger’s car-supply, but he will only say ‘Don’t ask’). He is the C.E.O. of RangeMan, Inc., a security company (among other things).

Stephanie’s relationship with Ranger, somewhere between boyfriend/girlfriend and teacher/pupil, provides much of her day-to-day stress, along with the almost constant threat of car bombing. Ranger says he loves Stephanie “in his own way” but isn’t the marrying type. Even if she is on with Morelli, it doesn’t stop Ranger from kissing or flirting with her, nor does she do much to discourage his advances. Regardless of his rivalry with Morelli, he has said that “Morelli is a good man” and is the marrying type Stephanie wants. Ranger does high-dollar or high-risk recovery for Vinnie, and sometimes lends Stephanie a hand with some of the more dangerous or slippery FTAs. He often assigns employees to guard or track her when she is in serious danger. Ranger “bleeds money” every time Stephanie requires protection, which is frequently; she minds, but he doesn’t so much – she actually appears as a line item in his budget (where she’s listed under “entertainment”).

As a result of him often coming to her aid or rescue, she has built up quite a tab with him and he has said that one day, he will collect.

Ranger will be played by Daniel Sunjata, who is most famous for his role as the hottie Franco Rivera on Rescue Me.   As for him playing Ranger? Two words… YES PLEASE!!!!!

I challenge you to watch Rescue Me and not think this man was carved out of a piece of heaven itself.  He is HOT!  He can play it cool and he can definitely play a ladies man, as I’m sure whoever came up with the term ladies man obviously met Franco Rivera!  Given the appropriate wardrobe and a good script, he CAN be Ranger, I’m certain of it.   To be honest, I’m not sure why I hadn’t come up with him myself when I was thinking of possibilities.  I think because I imagined Ranger to be harder, someone with a bit more of a rough look or perhaps having played more ‘fighty’ roles in the past (hence my choosing Dwayne ‘The Rock’ Johnson initially), but I think he can do it.  We’ve just not seen him in that kind of role yet, or I haven’t at least.

As with Heigl, I am 100% behind Sunjata as Ranger.  The jury is still out on the Morelli casting, I will have to look into the actor a bit more before I can say either way.

I’m excited about this, really friggin’ excited!  The more castings that happen and the closer the movie comes to being a reality, the more eager I am to see it.  Especially now after seeing these castings.  That said, it could all go to shit if they don’t choose wisely for Grandma Mazur and Lula, as they are pretty central characters that are loved by all.  Get those two wrong and they may as well not even bother making the film.

I will be keeping my eyes peeled for any casting news in regards to those two, for sure, but in the meantime… what do YOU think of these guys playing our leading men??

Check Also

TV Review: My Unexpected Love Affair With The Neighbors

One thing about TV is that it can sometimes surprise you.  Sometimes you are so …

Movie Review: One For The Money

Ok, this has been a long time coming but I think I’m finally able to …

245 comments

  1. Let me preface this by saying that I do love Katherine Heigl…BUT NOT AS STEPHANIE!! She just doesn’t do it for me! Does anyone watch Weeds?? Mary-Louise Parker! A constant train wreck waiting to happen, she is cool and funny but has “Balls”.You find your self rooting for her …
    Heigl just doesn’t ring for me. And I so wanted Niecy Nash as Lola.

  2. I almost want to boycott the movie, because I do not want my imagination to be totally shattered for future books. Their choice of Morelli, doesn’t even come close to hitting Stephanie’s ‘blissful predicament’. I do not want to pay and ‘hope’ O’Mara’s acting makes up for the difference. Nothing against O’Mara as an actor, I do not even know who he is. Morelli’s looks should be more tradational Italian, black hair,tan/olive skin…
    We like the books, why try to change what we imagine.
    At least they did good with their choice on Ranger.

  3. I would have preferred to see Whoopi Goldberg as Lula and Sandra Bullock as Stephanie.

  4. Here’s what I think:

    Stephanie – Katherine Heigl YES!
    Ranger – Daniel Sunjata YES!!
    Morelli – Eric Dane or Bradley Cooper??? idk SOMEONE SEXY!
    Lula – Loni Love
    Grandma Mazur – Ellen Albertini Dow YES!
    Mooner – Jason Mewes TOTALLY! haha
    Vinnie – Joe Pesci
    Joyce Barnhardt – Mary Lynn Rajskub (with her hair as it was in Sweet Home Alabama!)
    Debi Mazar – Connie

  5. The pick for Morelli is awful, horrible yikes.
    Debbie Reynolds as Grandma….no way…Betty White yes.
    Ranger is ok. Sandra Bullock where are you when we need you.

  6. I HATE that they cast Jason O’Mara. I think he looks a little too old and definatly not italian enough. I agree with casting Joe Manganiello (Alcinde from True Blood) That’s who I’ve been picturing as Morelli. I was watching a commercial for something else the other day and I think Rachel McAdams could pull off Stephanie, cute, spunky perfect. And she has blue eyes and brown hair! I really hope they don’t screw this up because i would love to see sequels. I always pictured Sophia from the golden girls as grandma Mazur. But I think that actress died.

  7. I would love Sandra Bullock as Stephanie.

  8. I really think Sandra Bullock would be much better than Katherine, but I have liked Katherine in everything she’s done. Definitely wrong choice for Morelli, but right on for Ranger. I also thought Queen Latifah would be great as Lula. A big NO to Debbie Reynolds, and a HELL YES to Betty White!!! I guess no matter what the movie will be fantastic, can’t wait!!!

  9. I’m just on Hot Six and loving these novels! I say give Jason O’Mara a chance, he could be good. He’s pretty hot and I think he’d do a good job bringing Morelli to life on the screen. I think the Ranger choice is terrific and I’m sure I’ll visualize him from now on, which is a very good thing. As for Stephanie, I’m totally not on board with Katherine Heigl. Loved her in Ugly Truth and Knocked Up, but I say no go on this one. Whoever posted Sandra Bullock or Anne Hathaway is right, I could see one of those two being Stephanie. Awkward enough to be goofy, pretty enough to be sexy, and either could pull off a great Jersey girl. I had no idea there was a movie in the works, so I’m excited!

  10. Katherine Heigl will be a decent stephanie i suppose, Sandra Bullock would have been 100 times better but w/e. Morelli…..NO, morelli has brown eyes that melt you, and is italian not this stupid irish crap. They cast Debbie Reynolds for Gma mazur (Love debbie reynolds, but betty white wouldve been better, imagine betty with a gun lol) they didnt cast queen latifah for lula :'( but the person they did cast definately looks able to play a big boned kick ass black ‘ho (sherri shepherd. Vinnie oughta be ok (Patrick Fischler) he is kinda weasley. oh well, still prolly gonna see it when it comes out on dvd.

  11. Everyone should remember that these people are actors. I thought Meryl Streep did a terrific job playing an Italian lady in Bridges of Madison County. The makeup people are also professionals. I’ll wait to see the movie.

    • You are right..except for Katherine Heigl is a terrible actor and can’t be compared to Meryl Streep…Hey! She could play Stephanie, she’d prolly do a hell of alot better.

  12. I just started reading this series a few months ago. I am up to book 11. I have been having a hard time picturing Morelli as someone from real life but seeing your choices has officially set Morelli in stone for me.

    Ten seconds ago I found out that there was going to be a movie and I am totally shocked at the choices. With the exception of Daniel Sunjata for Ranger I am shocked that they would choose non italian looking people for roles in a movie completely set in an Italian family and italian Jersey atmosphere.

    Jason O’Mara is a horrible choice for Morelli. Daniel Sunjata is a better choice for Ranger, but really he is not stacking up to the Rock. I have to say I wish they had you to do the casting! I can see Sandra Bullock playing Stephanie over Katherine Heigl but I think they need someone a little fresher.

    Did they even read the book?

  13. What about Antonio Sabato, Jr. for Ranger? He’d be perfect. Not sure about Morelli – but this guy is not a good choice.

    • I agree, Antonia Saboto Jr is my choice for Ranger. Also, Jason does NOT fit the bill for Morelli. My first choice would have been Eddie Cabrian, but would have settled for Eddie Cahill.

  14. It is interesting that Joe is an Italian, but the one picked to play him is Irish and the guy you would have picked is Scottish. Isn’t there any Italian actors that would fit the part? Both Jeffery and Jason are great looking guys.

  15. I was so excited when I heard there was going to be a movie about some of my favorite books. Now all I can think with this casting is that it is going to be an epic fail. I agree that Morelli, Grandma, and Stephanie are all wrong. I can sorta see Ranger and Lula may be spot on but, I feel that if they don’t fix these mistakes in casting, not many people will want to see the movie.

  16. Oh yea, Anne Hathaway would be a GOOD Stephanie.

    • I have to soooooo agree with you on this! My roomie and I sat here last night trying to decide on casting before we even knew the movie was being made and so said her!

  17. My sister has all of the Plum novels and I just started reading them for my self. Didn’t know there was a movie planned until I stumbled to your site. I was just wasting time today trying to find faces for all of the characters.

    The movie Morellie choice is all wrong. In my mind’s eye I see my High School crush Tim Sayers but not for the movie. I couldn’t decide between Zach Quinto or Dlyan McDermott. But if we go with the Ranger pick I’m going with Quinto.

    I considered Dewayne Johnson for the Benito role- he is attractive and beefy but too goofy. Besides I can’t imagine his hair grown out.

  18. Jason o’Mara looks nothing like Morelli! Epic fail! Why don’t producers ever pay attention to how a charecter is described in the book/s?
    Although…
    They did very well casting Ranger, Daniel Sunjata, although I have not heard of him looks exactly right.
    I do still think that Sandra Bullock would have made a much better Stephanie though, Heigel not only looks nothing like Stephanie but I don’t think she quite captures her as well as Sandra Bullock would.
    I really hope they cast Queen Latifah as Lula – She would be brilliant!

  19. OMG! Jason O’Mara for Morelli, no way, Jeffrey Dean Morgan would of been perfect and sexy like Morelli is supposed to be. The guy they have for Ranger is too pretty boy, they need someone who has a Special Forces edge like Ranger is supposed to be. Katherine Heigl is going to act her butt off and might be able to pull this off but Morelli guy might just ruin the movie!

  20. I really hope they DON’T cast Heigel as Stephanie. I like her..but she is NOT going to be believable in the role. For crying out loud she’s supposed to be of Italian heritage. Totally bummed in choices for Morelli and Ranger. Seriously look at the actor Alcide Herveaux of True Blood and tell me he isn’t a perfect match for Ranger.Dark,tall,muscular,tons of dark wavy hair, and he has that quality of mystery to him. Morelli would be best portrayed by actor Javier Bardem (Eat,Pray, Love) he’s also olive skinned and gorgeous and would be a great fit for that role. After reading all the books you just have a mindset of what the characters look like, and so far possible casting is beyond disappointing. How about Susan Sarandon for Steph’s mom?

  21. Since they did cast Heigl, Jeffrey Dean Morgan would be a good Morelli, they had great chemistry on Grey’s.

  22. I have been picturing Daniel Sunjata as my Ranger since Rescue Me’s first year. Great choice. I love Jason O’Mara, not exactly who I pictured for Joe, but may work. I have always pictured Angie Harmon for Stephanie and I am very disappointed in that casting.

  23. Okay, they have ranger spot on Daniel Sunjata he’s a hottie. But Jason O’Mara as Morelli, come on. Ugh, not Italian enough, come on the guy’s Irish. Definitely not handsome enough. Morelli has black curley hair, lean and mean looking. What were they thinking. I’m totally disappointed. I’m sure somewhere in the movie industry they could have come up with someone better, even an unknown.

    I love the Stephanie Plum novels, all the other characters are pretty much spot on, but this Joe is just so wrong.

    I only hope they get Grandma right.

    PS: I’d like to know who’s playing Connie.

    • Couldn’t agree more with you, Nancy. Who was the casting director on this pic? Their pick for Joe and Stephanie leave a lot to be desired. I mean can anyone other than Sandra Bullock be Stephanie? I heard they picked Sherry Shepard for Lula (yea! my pick) and looks like they did okay for Ranger. He was always a hard choice for me. I never bought into the Rock choice. I like Bitty Schramm for Connie, but haven’t heard anything about who she will be. And they’d better get Grandma right!

    • I love Katherine Hiegl as Stephanie Plum. I was totally thinking Dwayne Johnson as Ranger the moment I first read about him in the novels too!Morelli does deserve a hotter actor,i agree,than Jason O’Mara to fill his shoes.

      • I always pictured Dwayne Johnson for the part of Ranger and am happy to know that I was not the only one. I also pictured the actor who played Chacotay (spelling?) on Star Trek Voyager as Morelli. Maybe this casting will change my mind, but I am disappointed about The Rock not playing the part.

      • I have always been picturing Mark Wahlberg as Morelli

        • Every woman’s dream when reading these books are to place her self with Joe or Ranger. These guys do not turn me on!! Jim Caviezel as Joe in my cast!

  24. I so agree with you about your choice for Morelli. He really looks like Morelli to me, as opposed to who they chose. But I guess the on-screen chemistry will be the final test. They are actors, after all…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.